WORKPLACE SCENARIO 07
The Performance Conversation
What would you do?
Nomsa is an experienced member of a finance team. She has always been regarded as reliable, careful and highly capable.
Over the past few months, however, her manager, David, has noticed a change. Several reports have contained errors, two important pieces of work have been submitted late and colleagues have occasionally had to step in to help meet deadlines.
David has raised individual mistakes with Nomsa as they have occurred, but the pattern is continuing.
He knows that some menopause symptoms can affect concentration, memory, sleep and confidence. He also knows that he should not assume that menopause has anything to do with what is happening.
He asks Nomsa to meet privately.
David says:
"Nomsa, I want to talk about how things have been going recently. I've noticed several deadlines have been missed and there have been some errors in the monthly reports. That's unusual for you, so I wanted us to talk about what's happening and what we need to do from here."
Nomsa looks uncomfortable.
She replies:
"I know. I'm really frustrated with myself. I'm not performing the way I normally do."
Before we go any further...
What would you do if you were David?
There is a genuine performance issue here. The question is how to address it fairly without making assumptions about the cause.
Discuss:
- 1Was David right to raise the performance concerns?
- 2What has David done well in the way he opened the conversation?
- 3Should David ask Nomsa whether she is experiencing menopause?
- 4What might happen if David avoids discussing performance because he is worried about being insensitive?
- 5How can David separate the performance issue from assumptions about its cause?
- 6What would you say next if you were David?